• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

The 1901 Grill: Casual Dining with Smash Burgers & Scenic Views in Shelter Island Heights

Nestled in Shelter Island Heights, The 1901 Grill offers a relaxed, family-friendly dining experience with stunning deck views. Known for its standout smash burger—crispy, juicy, and packed with rich beef flavor—it’s a local favorite praised for quality and reasonable prices. The menu shines with solid dishes like buffalo wings, fresh Caesar salads, and pulled pork sandwiches, balancing hearty portions with fresh, well-executed flavors. Friendly, attentive service complements the inviting vibe, making it perfect for casual lunches or dinners after a day on the island. The 1901 Grill is truly a hidden gem worth discovering for comfort food with a scenic backdrop.

The 1901 Grill at a glance

  • Address 26 Sunnyside Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, United States
  • Phone (631) 749-5466
  • Restaurant type Restaurant , Bar , Bar & grill , Family restaurant , Lunch restaurant , Public golf course , Sports bar .

Photos & Gallery

The 1901 Grill: Reviews & Ratings

Mia DiOrio
5

Great food for very reasonable prices! ai especially love the smash burger and buffalo wings. The views from the deck are beautiful. I definitely recommend this hidden gem of a restaurant!

Don DeVries
4

Great smash burger at reasonable price. Very good beef flavor. Crisp and juicy. Perfect for lunch, dinner or after golf game. Enjoyed a side salad with blue cheese dressing. Fresh and perfect substitution for Fries.

Alexa
4

First time here since this location changed hands and became 1901. Service is outstanding, well coordinated and friendly. Not always something you experience this early in the season at other island venues. 1901 offers casual, good food. I ordered the fish and chips - fish was solid, french fries could be upgraded to a more tasty fry. Portion size for this entree is small, thus four stars. Another family member had the pulled pork sandwich and that was very good and filling. Overall, a solid choice for you to try - casual and tasty fare with a lovely view. .

Eden Benton
5

Super solid lunch with a pleasant view. Got the smash burger & Caesar salad, both were great! TBH wasn’t expecting much from the salad and was very pleasantly surprised, lettuce crispy and perfectly dressed. Would recommend

Andrew Puschel
5

This place is great! We (four adults and two children) went here on a rainy day and the food is great, the vibe is chill, local, and welcoming—casual and family-friendly without being only families. Views are great with blue sky or rain. Staff is friendly. The new owner came up and greeted us—wonderful guy. Highly recommend! We’ll be coming back!

julio MONTENEGRO
5

Great Buffalo wings. Nice a crispy just the way I like them. Amazing deal $18 for wings and a beer. Smash burger was to die for.

Mark Mobius
5

The food was even better than the spectacular views and comfortable summer dining atmosphere. We all loved the baked brie, the brussel sprouts, and the seared tuna appetizers. A high value experience at a refreshingly reasonable price for the area.

Angela Morales
5

Julia gave my table great recommendations and paired us with great wine. She made us feel welcomed and our other server as well when she checked in on us for dessert. Love the Buffalo wings and smash burger is a favorite! Had the salmon which was fantastic.

Location

  • The 1901 Grill
    The 1901 Grill
    26 Sunnyside Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, United States Hotline: (631) 749-5466

Located in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, The 1901 Grill offers a welcoming retreat where casual dining meets quality. This locally cherished restaurant, nestled at 26 Sunnyside Ave, sets itself apart with not only its inviting atmosphere but also its thoughtfully prepared menu that highlights classic American fare with a refined touch.

One cannot talk about The 1901 Grill without mentioning the much-lauded smash burger. Customers consistently praise its robust beef flavor, perfectly crisp exterior, and juicy interior, making it a standout choice for any meal of the day. Complementing the burger, the buffalo wings are a fiery, flavorful treat that adds a dynamic edge to the menu. For those seeking lighter options, salads like the crisp, expertly dressed Caesar or a fresh side salad with blue cheese dressing provide refreshing balance without compromising on taste.

The 1901 Grill extends beyond its food, offering diners a delightful ambiance with beautiful views from the deck. Whether the sun graces the sky or rain taps lightly on the windows, the setting creates an experience that enhances every bite. The staff’s attentive, friendly service and the personal touch of ownership presence underscore the community feel, making families and groups feel equally at home.

Dishes such as the fish and chips and pulled pork sandwich further showcase the kitchen’s dedication to comfort food done well—generous, satisfying portions paired with fresh, quality ingredients. While there is room for small refinement, particularly with the fries, the overall impression is that The 1901 Grill delivers solid, dependable meals with genuine flavor.

In summary, The 1901 Grill is a hidden gem that marries great food with beautiful views and warm hospitality. It invites both locals and visitors to enjoy a relaxed, flavorful dining experience that feels both familiar and special. For anyone exploring Shelter Island, this is a stop that truly rewards the palate and soothes the soul.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards