The 1901 Grill Menu

The 1901 Grill in Shelter Island Heights offers a delightful blend of casual dining with a stunning waterfront view. Known especially for its smash burger and buffalo wings, the menu strikes a perfect balance between quality and value. The beef in the smash burger comes through with a crisp and juicy texture, earning high praise from locals and visitors alike. Complementing the mains are thoughtful sides like a fresh Caesar or side salad, often preferred over fries for a lighter touch.

Seafood lovers will enjoy the reliable fish and chips, while the pulled pork sandwich satisfies with hearty, flavorful portions. The atmosphere is inviting and family-friendly, with attentive service that makes every visit pleasant. Whether you’re stopping in after a round of golf or catching a casual lunch, The 1901 Grill delivers solid, well-prepared dishes in a relaxed setting—making it a true hidden gem on the island.